Madison LeCroy revealed what she knows about Craig Conover’s dating life more than four months after his split from his longtime girlfriend Paige DeSorbo.
During an April 2025 appearance on ‘Watch What Happens Live,” the “Southern Charm” star was asked if she’s met Conover’s new girlfriend yet and if she thought he jumped into another relationship too “soon.”
“Well, I’m not really sure if it’s a girlfriend,” LeCroy replied. “I know that he has been single for the last three months. He did get dumped, so I know that he is dating around and doing what single guys do. So I don’t think it was too soon.”
LeCroy’s comment came a week after Conover was a guest on “Watch What Happens Live” and confirmed to host Andy Cohen that he was seeing someone.
“I’m really happy,” the South Carolina businessman said. “You know, when I date, I tend to date only one person at a time. So, I’ve been seeing someone, and it’s been, I’ve been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways, but everything happens for a reason.”
Andy Cohen Said He Met Conover’s Rumored New Flame
Conover has been reportedly dating model and influencer Natalie Buffett, a source told Us Weekly just after his WWHL appearance. The insider said Conover briefly dated Buffett in 2019—well before his relationship with DeSorbo— but wasn’t in a place for a serious relationship at the time. Five years later, he’s reportedly “smitten” with the blonde influencer. The source noted that Conover “always believes in signs and things working out if they are meant to be” and is all-in this time around.
The Instagram gossip account Deux Moi also claimed that Buffett was in the audience of Conover’s WWHL taping and later spotted at the airport with him.
LeCroy did not confirm if Buffett was the woman that Conover is dating. She also told Cohen that she has not met his new flame.
Cohen then dropped a comment that conflicted with the story that Buffett was in the WWHL audience one week prior. “Funnily enough, I believe as it turns out if it is the person I think, that I have met her,” the Bravo host teased. “In a non-Bravo situation, I’ve met her, yes.”
Paige DeSorbo Doesn’t Care Who Craig Conover Is Dating
As rumors about Conover’s dating life swirl, a source told Us Weekly that DeSorbo doesn’t care what he’s doing and doesn’t have time to think about it. “Paige isn’t fazed by Craig dating,” the insider said of the ”Summer House” star’s reaction to her ex’s new flame.
“She’s a hot commodity and people are always trying to date her,” the source added of DeSorbo, before noting that the “Giggly Squad” host doesn’t want to be “bogged down” in a relationship as she focuses on her career.
