EXPOSED: Craig Conover's New Romance with Natalie Buffett Began Before Paige DeSorbo Split — A Deep Betrayal Unveiled!

Southern Charm fans are questioning the dating history of Craig Conover and his new girlfriend, Natalie Buffett. Although he and Paige DeSorbo split at the end of 2024, there is a strange timeline issue, and fans have noticed it. So, what are they saying about Craig and Natalie? Keep reading for further details.

Southern Charm Fans Question Craig & Natalie’s Dating History

Craig Conover was hurt and blindsided by his split from Paige DeSorbo. The Southern Charm star had bought his girlfriend of three years a pricey engagement ring, and they even planned an overseas New Year’s trip. Unfortunately, the writing was on the wall that they were not meant to be. He was passionate about getting married and having a family whereas Paige’s career was exploding. She wanted to make that her focus and never cared about relocating to Charleston, where Craig was based. After it ended, she was spotted out with a new man and recently, Craig shared that he has found a new love.

He started dating Natalie Buffett, a woman from his past who had resurfaced again. They dated briefly back in 2019, but then it fizzled. She was with him when he appeared on WWHL recently, plus she was spotted at the Charleston airport. However, fans have been paying close attention to Craig and his relationship history with Natalie. They believe that he may have started reconnecting with her right after Paige broke up with him. Someone shared this tidbit:

• According to new reports, craig started talking to Natalie (girl he’s dating) around NYE! that explains why on giggly squad Paige said she decided to announce because “he was acting single” on his trip.

They also added that Paige was catching heat for having someone new so fast, yet Craig was gallivanting as well. The Southern Charm OG has not made his relationship with Natalie Buffett public but it is clear something magical is happening. He admitted that he is very happy with his new lady and was grinning from ear to ear.

The Fishy Timing

After learning when the Southern Charm star began speaking with Natalie Buffett, what did fans think? Was everyone convinced that he was just as guilty as Paige DeSorbo, or did they not put much stock in this timeline? Craig Conover has been known for lying and creating stories; therefore, they feel he was never thoroughly transparent:

• Didn’t he say on the southern charm reunion that he hadn’t gone on any dates yet and wasn’t interesting dating anyone until he was “fully healed”?? When was that filmed?!
• Craig’s rebound girlfriend, being 10 years younger than him, is just about the least surprising thing I’ve ever read about that man.
• I’m convinced that he is a sociopath. The way he lies, has bragged about being a good liar, lies about lying, gaslights people… bullies people… all while acting like this victim.

Nothing surprises fans any longer. Finally, they believe everything Paige has ever said about the Southern Charm star. What do you think about Craig and Natalie, and do you feel their timeline is somewhat fishy? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.