Susie Evans quit Bachelor In Paradise after rejecting Justin Glaze’s rose. But before she caused drama for Justin and Lexi Young, Susie went on a date with Jeremy Simon. After her exit, Jeremy talked producers into letting him call her. He asked her to come back to the show. She said no, but he can’t get her out of his mind. Jeremy has been clear to everyone but Bailey that he wants another chance with Susie.
He might get it. Fans think Susie is coming back to the beach before the season is over.
Susie Evans Reveals Where She Stands With Justin Glaze Now
Susie Evans and Justin Glaze met after her relationship with Clayton Echard ended. He was a contestant on Katie Thurston’s Bachelorette season. Susie and Justin started as friends but their feelings eventually turned romantic.
They played coy for months before admitting that they were, in fact, dating. They broke up after a year together. Justin and Susie were spotted together again a few months later, but never confirmed they were dating again. They admitted on Bachelor In Paradise that they briefly reconciled in secret.
Susie and Justin broke up again in January 2025. A few months later they both headed to Costa Rica for Season 10 of Bachelor In Paradise. He arrived first and connected with Lexi Young from Joey Graziadei’s Bachelor season.
However, Lexi wasn’t sure that Justin was over Susie and was hesitant to get invested. Of course that was Susie’s cue to arrive on the beach. Susie and Justin hashed out their relationship and were ready to move on with other people.
But by that point, Justin wasn’t sure about his connection with Lexi anymore. When it came time to hand out his rose, he tried to give it to Susie so she could stay on the show. She rejected the rose because she didn’t want to step on Lexi’s toes. Justin, Susie and Lexi quit the show after the dramatic rose ceremony.
Susie Evans was recently on The Viall Files podcast. She opened up about where she stands with both Justin and Lexi now.
“I have talked with Justin, I have talked with Lexi. Adore them both, I think they’re both really great people and yeah, good vibes all around.”
Bachelor In Paradise Fans Think Susie Returns To Season 10
There won’t be good vibes all around Bachelor In Paradise when Bailey Brown finds out that Jeremy Simon is pining for Susie still. Jeremy confided in Brian Autz about his feelings for Susie. Viewers are eagerly waiting for Brian to spill the secret to Bailey.
The trailer for the next episode teases that Brian finally tells Bailey. But some Bachelor In Paradise fans are convinced a previous trailer hinted at Susie Evans’ return to the beach.
One fan wrote that it was “obvious” that Susie comes back. But another viewer wrote, “Susie would not come back to that drama.”
There hasn’t been an official confirmation that Susie Evans returns to Bachelor In Paradise but it could be a well-kept secret. Do you think she comes back?
