Lindsay Hubbard said she already heard rumblings that Craig Conover was talking to other women during his relationship with Paige DeSorbo, and Lindsay has since “texted Paige about” it. The Summer House star also called Jesse Solomon “messy,” and Gabby Prescod suggested he was dishonest concerning his “narrative” about Lexi Wood.
Jesse and Lexi’s romance bloomed at the beginning of the season, and he soon met her family. But Lexi told Jesse that she “doesn’t like to share” and has a tendency to get jealous. Jesse, however, seemed less than thrilled with the idea of getting serious. Later in the season, Lexi seemingly accused Ciara Miller of being flirty with him.
At the end of 2024, Lindsay’s co-star Paige shared that she and Craig split. Later on, as rumors surfaced that she allegedly cheated on him, Craig remained silent. In response, Paige accused Craig of communicating with other women during their relationship.
On the Virtual Reali-Tea podcast, Lindsay was asked if she had already heard rumblings that Craig was talking to other women amid his relationship with Paige.
“Did you bug my apartment?” asked Lindsay. “I had heard stuff through the grapevine a long time ago, that I’ve since texted Paige about.”
“But that’s not my circus,” she went on. “Not my sink, not my dishes.”
At one point in the interview, Lindsay addressed Jesse.
“‘Messy’ is the best word you can use for Jesse,” she said, “Like in this season. Because it was just, it got real messy. I think my role that I tried to play with Jesse and Lexi specifically was … being there for each of them. I felt like Jesse needed support from the female side, which he got a lot of.”
“But then I also was one of the closest ones to Lexi — along with [Gabby] — so I could give the best support from her end without it being her,” she said.
Gabby added that she initially “heard a lot from Jesse” himself, as she and Lexi didn’t start to “get closer” until the middle of the summer.
“He’s a gossip. He loves to chat,” said Gabby. “I’m eating it up too. Like I love to get tea.” But eventually, Gabby felt his story was “a little weird.”
“And [then] I would hear it from her side eventually, and we started putting the pieces together,” she said. “And then I was like, ‘Oh okay. So, like, this is not true.'” According to Gabby, when Jesse caused tension between Ciara and Lexi, the women “clocked it pretty quickly.”
She added, “So … I don’t think anyone had to necessarily get involved until he started denying.”
