Paige DeSorbo Exposes Craig’s Cold Betrayal and New Girlfriend — Heartbreak Deeper Than Ever After Learning He’s Already Moved On

Summer House's Paige DeSorbo kept her and Craig Conover's breakup under wraps — until his alleged post-split actions apparently left her no choice.

The couple of three years initially split in late November 2024 and officially ended their relationship in mid-December during a face-to-face conversation, about two weeks later. However, as Paige revealed on the Summer House Season 9 Reunion Part 1, they "didn't discuss how the breakup would go after," in terms of making a public announcement. 

"But I told him that I was going to put a statement out on my podcast when I realized he was, like, on vacation being single," Paige explained to host Andy Cohen. "I was like, OK, well I can't hide this anymore from people."

When the Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen host asked what she meant by Craig "was on vacation being single," the Giggly Squad co-host referenced an Aspen trip her ex took "right when Christmas happened," i.e. very shortly after they called it quits.

"He was out at bars, there were girls around, people had pictures, they were on the internet, and I was like, 'I'm not gonna respond to that,'" Paige added. "I'd rather be the one to say, 'We broke up; he's fine to, like, be out right now and be doing his thing.'"

She subsequently announced their "very sad" breakup on December 30.

What Paige DeSorbo said about Craig Conover's engagement ring claims and his "new girlfriend"

As for the engagement ring Craig said he had custom-made for Paige, she doubled down on her declaration from the Summer House finale, telling Andy, "That ring does not exist."

When Andy pointed out that the Southern Charm-er told him during a March 27 WWHL appearance "that he returned the ring that day," Paige remained incredulous, also referencing Craig's new love interest. 

"How convenient," she responded. "The day he's on [Watch What Happens Live], him and his new girlfriend went and returned my ring? I don't think so, Andy. That's insane."

Insisting that she knows Craig "very well," the podcaster added, "I know his tells when he's lying. … A custom ring, no one's letting you return it a year later."  

Paige DeSorbo reveals new Craig Conover breakup details

Though the Sewing Down South co-founder previously said he was "blindsided" by Paige breaking up with him, well, she didn't exactly buy that claim either. "I mean, Craig and I have had this conversation for a year," Paige said on the Summer House Reunion Part 1. "Like, it's not like one day I just woke up and was like, 'I think I'll be single today.'"

In fact, she further detailed how she and Craig previously split in February 2024 "for, like, a full weekend," though they got back together soon after talking out their issues.

"So, it's not like it was smooth sailing, and then one day I was just like, 'See ya!'" Paige elaborated, throwing up her deuces. "We've had these conversations over and over and over."

Regardless, the Summer House cast member said she "tried everything in [her] power" to not turn their split into a Team Paige vs. Team Craig scenario. "But he wasn't gonna let me go easy," she concluded.