Paige DeSorbo Reveals If She Regrets Choosing Craig Conover Over ‘Summer House’ Co-Star

Paige DeSorbo says she has no regrets about her three-year relationship with Craig Conover – or the fact that she passed up her handsome  ”Summer House” co-star, Andrea Denver, to be with him.  

Both men pursued DeSorbo at the same time in 2021. But five months after her breakup from Conover, DeSorbo appeared on “Watch What Happens Live” and was asked the shadiest of questions: “Do you now wish you chose Andrea over Craig?

“Nooooo,” DeSorbo laughed in response.

DeSorbo previously told Page Six that she “felt so much more of a pull” to Conover than to anyone else she was talking to at the time. She also noted that she’d had a crush on Conover for years after seeing him on “Southern Charm.”

“I think Andrea is amazing,” DeSorbo said of the Italian model in early 2022. “I have nothing but the sweetest things to say about him. He’s definitely stuck with me as a friend for a while.”

Denver went on to marry “Project Runway” alum Lexi Sundin in June 2024.

Paige DeSorbo Said She Should Date an Italian Man Next

Elsewhere on WWHL, DeSorbo was asked what type of guy she should date next.

“I really want someone funny,” she told host Andy Cohen. “I’m sick of being the funny one. I want somebody to make me laugh. So, I think just funny and good-looking, obviously, and rich.”

“Honestly, I don’t typically have a type, but I never really go for blondes, so I would say like brown hair, dark eyes,” she added. “I love an Italian, I should be with an Italian next.”

DeSorbo previously told Parade she is also “ready for a man who can dress really well.” “I think in New York City, the guys have been kind of lackadaisical with their outfits, and I just don’t want to see a Chelsea boot ever again. So, I think someone [who] is really into their own outfits,” she explained.

Paige DeSorbo Would Take the ‘Hate’ Over Her Breakup Again To Be Where She is Today

Getty

During her appearance on WWHL, DeSorbo noted that she received more hate than she had expected when she broke things off with Conover last fall.

“There’s definitely misogyny in the world. I feel like I definitely got hit with a lot of it,” she said. “I’m on reality TV… It’s kind of part of the operation, and I would take the hate 10 times over if it meant I’m at where I am in my life now. So I’m fine with it,” the “Giggly Squad” co-host added.

In an interview with People magazine, DeSorbo admitted that she “wouldn’t have done anything differently,” regarding her breakup with the Sewing Down South founder.

“I would have taken the Facebook-over-65 mom hate 10 times over if it meant the same outcome and that I chose myself and what I wanted,” she explained.

She also described the outrage over her choosing her career over marriage as “wild.” “It’s like, ‘How dare she break up with a man who’s over six foot and wants to marry her? Is she crazy?’” DeSorbo cracked.