In a heartbreaking confession that exposes the quiet unraveling behind one of Love Is Blind’s most complex relationships, Garrett Josemans is finally speaking his truth — and it’s not the polished love story fans were hoping for.
After months of trying to break through Taylor Krause’s walls, Garrett admits he’s reached a breaking point — not because he stopped loving her, but because he doesn’t know how to keep loving someone who won’t let him in.
“It’s Like She’s Punishing Me for What Someone Else Did”
“There’s a version of Taylor I only get glimpses of,” Garrett said, his voice thick with emotion. “The one who laughs in the kitchen. The one who lets her guard down for a second. And then it’s gone. Like she catches herself and slams the door shut.”
Garrett says he’s spent most of their relationship trying to prove he’s not the villain in her story — trying to love her the way she deserves to be loved, but constantly being met with silence, hesitation, and fear.
“She says she wants love — but every time I offer it, she flinches.”
An Invisible Battle No One Sees
While the cameras captured tender kisses and whispered promises, Garrett says what viewers didn’t see were the late-night arguments, the cold shoulders, the emotional push-pull that left him drained.
“She’s not cruel. She’s just guarded. But after a while, it starts to feel like I’m bleeding for someone who won’t even reach for a bandage.”
“I’m Not Asking Her to Be Perfect — I’m Just Asking Her to Let Me In”
According to Garrett, he’s not expecting Taylor to erase her past or magically become someone else overnight. He just wants to be trusted. To not have to fight every day to prove he’s not going to disappear.
“I know she’s scared. I know she’s been hurt,” he said. “But I’m not the one who left. I’m not the one who lied. I’m the one who’s still here — and I’m tired of feeling like that’s not enough.”
Is Love Enough If It’s One-Sided?
As for where they go from here, Garrett says he doesn’t have the answers. Just one aching question: “What else do I have to do to be enough for her?”
Because love isn’t supposed to feel like chasing someone through quicksand. And Garrett’s starting to wonder if holding on to Taylor means losing pieces of himself.
