When Susie Evans showed up on the beach in Costa Rica, fans were hoping it was to reconcile with Justin Glaze. The two Bachelor Nation stars became friends in 2022. While they began dating in 2023, they played coy and kept it to themselves until early 2024.
The couple announced in the summer that they had broken up. But they admitted on Bachelor In Paradise that they got back together before breaking up again in early 2025.
When Susie arrived on the beach, Justin had been getting to know Lexi Young. Lexi was initially unsure about it because his breakup with Susie was still fresh. But she eventually got over her fears. However, by that time, Justin wasn’t interested in continuing things with Lexi. During a rose ceremony earlier this season, he offered his rose to Susie.
She rejected it because she didn’t want to be the reason Lexi went home. But the drama ended with Lexi, Susie, and Justin all quitting Season 10. While Justin and Susie did talk about their relationships, viewers will want more details.
Susie Initiated The Split
Susie and Justin were friends long before things turned romantic. And they’re still friends today. But as anyone who has ever been in a relationship, someone always initiates the breakup.
Justin Glaze claimed that the split was mutual and they both wanted to end the relationship. When pressed further, he admitted that Susie was the one who initiated the split.
Justin Glaze Shares More Insight
Justin Glaze was a guest on Bachelorette alum Jason Tartick’s podcast this week. He was asked to give the real reason his relationship with Susie ended.
The Bachelor In Paradise star said again that the split was mutual but initiated by Susie. Justin Glaze shared more insight on what led to the split. He denied that there was a fight or cheating or any huge event that caused the breakup. He shared that they were simply too different and wanted different things in life.
View this post on Instagram
Ultimately, they decided that they were better as friends instead of in a relationship. But fans still hope they can overcome the obstacles.
Fans React To What He Said
According to some Bachelor Nation fans, Justin Glaze said a lot of words to essentially say nothing. He didn’t address any specifics about what led to Susie ending their relationship. Fans of the show roasted him in the comments for giving them nothing.
- “Is the reason in the room with us?”
- “I have no further understanding than before”
- “Word Salad”
- “Nothing was said”
- “What are the deal breakers ? Still no answers here”
But one fan said it was a green flag that Justin continued to respect Susie’s privacy by not sharing details. Why do you think they broke up?
