Kristin Cavallari accuses Craig Conover of lying about 'overlap' with Paige Desorbo after revealing how many times they had sex

Kristin Cavallari met up with Craig Conover for the first time in years during her podcast tour on E!'s Honestly Cavallari: The Headline Tour, where she accused him of some 'overlap' in their hookup and his relationship with Paige DeSorbo.

The 38-year-old reality star had previously denied hooking up with the 36-year-old Summer House star back in 2022, though she recently came clean on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen earlier this month.

She admitted that they were 'romantic for two seconds,' adding, 'The second I caught wind of Paige, I very politely excused myself from the situation.'

Cavallari welcomed both Conover and his Summer House co-star Austen Kroll during her Boston tour stop, where she revealed how many times they had hooked up.

Kroll also set the record straight that he and Cavallari were never romantic, but she did ask Conover about any 'overlap' in their tryst and him dating DeSorbo, who he dated from October 2021 to December 2024.

While they were discussing how they first met, Cavallari bluntly asked Conover, 'Did you lie to me about Paige?' which clearly stunned Conover.

'What?' Conover said with a weak laugh, as Kroll said, 'Kristin!' as she added, 'I definitely think there was a little overlap.'

She added, 'I remember asking you and you were like, "No, nothing's going on,' as Conover said, 'No, I don't think there's as much overlap as everyone thinks,' though clearly the audience didn't believe him judging from their reactions.

He added, 'I honestly believe, like we were such good friends,' as Kristin admitted, 'I'm not saying we were dating, we weren't dating.'

'I actually am an honest person, like I never lied to you about anything,' Craig admitted, adding, 'Eventually, it just got to the point Paige and I decided to date and we stopped talking.'

Kristin admitted, 'Once I kind of caught wind of Paige, I was like, I'm gonna remove myself from this situation.'

She did confirm in a confession that there was, 'more than kissing' going on with Craig, as she confirmed more in a flashback. 

During a flashback, Kristin's BFF Justin Anderson asked if her vagina is safe and she fired back with, 'Ask Craig.'

'How many times did I hook up with Craig? I think it was honestly like once or twice. It wasn't that much,' she said.

They played a drinking game and she was dared to kiss Craig but he slyly told her he was dating someone and they didn't kiss.

After Craig and Austen left the stage, Craig said, 'This is about the dumbest thing that I've ever done in my life. The whole f***ing thing was Paige. That was crazy.'

When Kristin joined them backstage, Craig said, 'Kristin, if I wasn't dating someone, I would have kissed you on stage, but I was like, no one knows I'm dating someone,' he said of his girlfriend Natalie Buffett.

She did admit that all of the drama swirling around her and Craig was a 'wake-up call,' adding, 'It definitely made me kind of take a step back and realize that I kind of needed to reel things in a little bit.'