Bachelor In Paradise viewers saw Golden contestants Gary Levingston and Leslie Fhima form a close friendship and possible romance on Season 10. But one Bachelor Nation fan dropped a major bombshell that Gary is secretly dating Theresa Nist. Keep reading for more on this shocking rumor.
Gary Levingston & Leslie Fhima Reunite After Bachelor In Paradise Exit
Gary Levingston and Leslie Fhima were the first to be eliminated once Bachelor In Paradise changed format from a dating show to a competition for $500,000. They were among the couples with the lowest scores during that week’s challenge.
When leaving the show, Gary assured viewers that he would stay in touch with Leslie and possibly pursue a romance. During a recent podcast appearance after their exit, Leslie clarified that she’s just friends with Gary for now. She mentioned that they live in different states, which makes dating difficult.
But then Gary posted a video on social media of him and Leslie hanging out at Lake Tahoe. They certainly looked cozy for “just friends.”
Is He Secretly Dating Theresa Nist
Leslie Fhima and Theresa Nist were in competition on the first Golden Bachelor season for Gerry Turner’s love. Gerry chose Theresa, though their relationship ended shortly afterward.
If one Bachelor Nation fan is to be believed, Leslie and Theresa are again involved in a love triangle. This time with Gary Levingston. A fan claimed that Theresa and Gary have been secretly dating for months.
Another fan unearthed a photo of Theresa and Gary at Lake Tahoe, though it was unclear when it was taken. There isn’t any verified proof that Gary and Theresa are dating, but stranger things have happened in the Bachelor Nation franchise.
Golden Bachelor Contestant Claims Gary Levingston Had ‘History’ With Nancy Hulkower
Gary Levingston got ribbed by the other Golden men for being the playboy of Bachelor In Paradise. Gary was a hot commodity, going on several dates and hangouts with the senior women.
In fact, Leslie Fhima claimed on the Bachelor Happy Hour podcast that Gary had a pre-show history with Nancy Hulkower. Leslie didn’t know the details, and whether it was texting or DMs. However, Leslie said Nancy only joined the show for Gary. Furthermore, Leslie said that Kathy Swarts told her that Gary was only there for Nancy.
Nancy and Gary did enjoy a cacao-fueled date. But then Gary gave his rose to Leslie and Nancy went home. Gary and Leslie teamed up on the next challenge, which ultimately was their demise.
If the rumors are true, Gary Levingston has his choice between Leslie Fhima, Theresa Nist, and Nancy Hulkower. What do you think about the rumors that Gary and Theresa are dating? Could you see them as a couple? Sound off in the comments.
